Monday, May 20, 2013

Day 797
Forum Syria’s Business Elite: Shifting Away from Assad

Syria’s Business Elite: Shifting Away from Assad

Syria’s business elite has long been a pillar of support for the Assad regime, in an odd alliance that linked wealthy capitalists with a socialist military dictatorship.

Over the past few years, they rode a wave of market reforms that spurred the country’s economic growth. One mark of Bashar al Assad’s reign was the sudden appearance of shopping malls, boutique hotels and private banks in Damascus – all practically absent from Syria until his reforms took effect in 2004. That new prosperity boosted stability, thickening ties between the regime and business leaders, while cementing their shared interest in a stable Syria.

But with the start of the revolution, attention turned to whether and when those business leaders – the executive class in Damascus – would abandon Assad.

Now, it seems they largely have. The death toll and brutal abuses by the regime have pushed them away.

“I don’t know any of them who are still for Assad…they’re all against what’s happening,” says one prominent businessman based in Damascus. “They don’t believe Assad anymore,” he adds. “Every time he turns up on TV his ratings drop.”

He named a number of business families, with empires from automotives to manufacturing to soft drinks, who’ve openly denounced the regime. One of those families was materially helping the rebels, until members of their own clan were abducted by security forces – a message that even the biggest merchant families aren’t out of the regime’s reach.

“The regime has lost large segments of the business community, but it doesn’t make much of a difference for them,” says Jihad Yazigi, editor-in-chief of The Syria Report, an online business magazine.

In other words, as Syria’s government fights for its survival, the business elite have become largely irrelevant. They aren’t supporting the regime like they used to, and yet that hasn’t been the game-changer many thought it would be.

“Has there been a shift in the business community? Absolutely,” says Ayham Kamel of the Eurasia Group.

“But even in a scenario where they were all against him, that would not be decisive,” he adds.  “The military, intelligence, and the security services are decisive, and the majority of them are still loyal.” It’s that support which enables Assad to keep up his crackdown, as he tries to take back chunks of Syria that are now under rebel control.

Business, in Political Limbo 

Even though they’ve shifted away from Assad, the business community is in political limbo: not with the regime, but not comfortable with the alternative. The Sunni business elite, while religiously conservative, do not want a future Syria led by the Muslim Brotherhood. And the opposition leaders they see abroad don’t inspire their confidence.

“The likes of the Syrian National Council are irrelevant to us inside Syria. We don’t know these people or what they represent,” says the Damascus businessman. “A deal will have to be struck” with the regime, before business leaders openly endorse political change.

Some business families have been hedging their political bets.

“I know of businessmen who’ve supported both the rebels and the government at the same time, for many months,“ Yazigi says.

At a time when picking sides could be lethal, there would have to be a clear winner before they openly place a bet.

 

  • Alex

    Great article. I agree that the defection of the wealthy businessmen will be key, but it alone (as the article points out) will not end the regime. Still though, it will deal a crippling blow to the regime (and weaken it severely). This is because it is one of the pillars of regime support and, in my view, is a key source of funds (since they are wealthy businessmen). Thus, losing their support and funds as well as being hurt by sanctions would cause the regime to be hurt financially and politically. However, as the article says, the businessmen have not completely turned against Assad. Some are “neutral”; they are not completely pro-regime, but they haven’t supported opposition either. Plus, as this article points out- http://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/galleries/2012/07/08/syria-s-thriving-elites-kate-brooks-photos.html- some have kept supporting the regime due to their interests. The fact that the SNC is unable to gain traction, unite, form a real transition plan, and conduct outreach to those who are uncertain (business elite, Syria’s minority groups, etc) about the revolution only makes efforts to get the businessmen to defect harder. I wonder how many will defect in the future, but it’s tough to call. I personally do not see a significant number of defections happening soon, given how things are in Syria (bloody stalemate and SNC disunity/lack of organization, etc).

Comments

Alex 04-11-2012, 22:42

Great article. I agree that the defection of the wealthy businessmen will be key, but it alone (as the article points out) will not end the regime. Still though, it will deal a crippling blow to the regime (and weaken it severely). This is because it is one of the pillars of regime support and, in my view, is a key source of funds (since they are wealthy businessmen). Thus, losing their support and funds as well as being hurt by sanctions would cause the regime to be hurt financially and politically. However, as the article says, the businessmen have not completely turned against Assad. Some are “neutral”; they are not completely pro-regime, but they haven’t supported opposition either. Plus, as this article points out- http://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/galleries/2012/07/08/syria-s-thriving-elites-kate-brooks-photos.html- some have kept supporting the regime due to their interests. The fact that the SNC is unable to gain traction, unite, form a real transition plan, and conduct outreach to those who are uncertain (business elite, Syria’s minority groups, etc) about the revolution only makes efforts to get the businessmen to defect harder. I wonder how many will defect in the future, but it’s tough to call. I personally do not see a significant number of defections happening soon, given how things are in Syria (bloody stalemate and SNC disunity/lack of organization, etc).

Newsletter

Ali Ferzat’s Sarcastic Revolution

May 19, 2013

Ali Ferzat is a renowned Syrian political cartoonist and the creator of more than 15,000 published drawings. In August 2011, Ferzat was reportedly dragged out of his car while driving in central Damascus by masked forces loyal to Bashar al-Assad’s regime. His fingers were systematically broken and he was left for dead by the side [...]

Syria Deeply Asks: What is the Relationship Like Between Russia and Syria?

May 17, 2013

As a regular feature, inspired by your questions about the Syria conflict, we’ve rounded up answers from some of the top minds in our network. If you’d like to submit a question for us to tackle, send it to ask@newsdeeply.org. Question: What is the relationship like between Syria and Russia? (Via Quora) Salman Shaikh, director of [...]

Arts + Culture: War in Syria’s Wine Country

May 16, 2013

Another winter has passed at Domaine de Bargylus, and once-twisted, gray-barked vines are today burgeoning with green buds. Spring is a precarious season, when a late frost can decimate a vineyard’s chances of ever yielding a harvest. Like the majority of their countrymen, the owners of this young estate, Syrian brothers Karim and Sandro Saadé, [...]

Three Men in Raqqa Executed in Retaliation for Banias Massacre

May 17, 2013

The following post first appeared at the Brown Moses Blog.  The following videos were posted online today from the city of Raqqa, which has been under the control of Jihadist Syrian opposition groups for the past several weeks. (Graphic) The videos show the execution of three men described as Assad army officers, knelt in the middle of a [...]

Egypt and Syrian Refugees: It’s Complicated

May 16, 2013

Every time I have to travel to Egypt, my heart jumps with joy like a little girl about to go to an amusement park. Egypt has and will always have a special place in my heart. It was the place I was born, it’s where I went to university, where I first fell in love, [...]

Young Brides’ Dreams Crushed Among Syrian Civil War

May 15, 2013

The following post first appeared at CBSNews.com.  ZAATARI REFUGEE CAMP, Jordan — It is impossible for most of us to understand what life is like for the more than half-million Syrian refugees living in Jordan. Most have fled the violence and chaos of Syria’s civil war only to themselves trapped in a life of grinding [...]